Pilatus can continue to work in Saudi Arabia and the UAE
A Pilatus PC-21 aircraft being worked on in Stans, canton Nidwalden.
Keystone / Urs Flueeler
Swiss aircraft manufacturer Pilatus can continue its business activities in Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates (UAE), a court has confirmed. The Swiss foreign ministry had banned the company from operating in the Gulf states.
This content was published on
2 minutes
Keystone-SDA/sb
العربية
ar
محكمة فدرالية تسمح لشركة بيلاتوس باستئناف العمل في السعودية والإمارات
In a ruling published on Friday, the Federal Administrative Court in St Gallen annulled a foreign ministry decision in June 2019 to ban the Stans-based aircraft manufacturer from operating in the two countries.
The ministry had claimed that the support services offered by Pilatus to the armed forces of Saudi Arabia and the UAE, which include technical support, replacement parts management and fixing problems with a fleet of 55 Pilatus PC-21 military trainer aircraft, were “not compatible with the [Swiss] government’s foreign policy objectives”.
A US-backed Saudi Arabia-led military coalition, of which the UAE is a part, intervened in Yemen in 2015, backing government forces fighting the Iran-backed Houthis rebels. Years of United Nations efforts to get both sides to agree to a cease-fire and start peace negotiations have not succeeded.
The latest Swiss court ruling upheld an appeal by Pilatus. The St Gallen judges pointed out that the aircraft manufacturer is one of the largest employers in central Switzerland. It is part of the country’s “technological and industrial base” that ensures the country’s long-term security, it said.
When making its decision, the foreign ministry should have taken into account “public interest considerations” such as the maintenance of the Switzerland’s prosperity and independence, the court said. These “superior state interests” are covered by the Federal Act on Private Security Services Provided AbroadExternal link and allow exceptional authorisations for activities that are normally prohibited, it said.
An exceptional authorisation is only granted if organisations do not directly participate in a conflict and ensure that any services rendered are not used to commit serious human rights violations, it added.
The court said the foreign ministry had imposed the ban without referring to the Federal Council (executive body), which normally grants authorisations in exceptional circumstances. The foreign ministry “carried out political assessment which was not its responsibility”, it concluded.
The St Gallen court’s ruling can still be appealed at the higher Federal Court.
More
More
Pilatus challenges ‘export ban’ to Saudi Arabia and UAE
This content was published on
The Swiss aircraft manufacturer takes the foreign ministry to court for banning the company from operating in Saudi Arabia and the UAE.
Bodycams: essential for good law enforcement, or a privacy risk?
Did you ever come across bodycams in your place of residence and if so, how do you think the use of bodycams alter the relationship between the public and (transport) police?
This content was published on
Swiss wheelchair racer Catherine Debrunner won the 5,000 metres to bring home Switzerland’s first gold medal at the Paralympics in Paris.
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.
Read more
More
Swiss-Saudi talks to take place amid export ban
This content was published on
Swiss State Secretary for Foreign Affairs Pascale Baeriswyl is to fly to Saudi Arabia for political talks that come amid an export row.
India cancels Pilatus aircraft purchase amid corruption probe
This content was published on
The Indian Air Force has reportedly decided to forego the purchase of 38 Pilatus training planes from the Swiss manufacturer.
Row over ‘export ban’ to Saudi Arabia takes new turn
This content was published on
Switzerland’s prosecutor's office has opened a criminal investigation in connection with the sale of training aircraft to Saudi Arabia and the UAE.
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.