Study: Cross-border workers do not steal Swiss jobs
Cross-border commuters working in Switzerland do not replace the local workforce. On the contrary, they can have a beneficial impact on the Swiss labour market, according to Sylvain Weber, the co-author of a study on this controversial issue.
This content was published on
2 minutes
Journalist and deputy head of the swissinfo.ch editorial group for German, French and Italian. Earlier, worked for Teletext and Switzerland’s French-language national broadcaster.
“An increase in the flow of cross-border commuters is not followed by an increase in the indigenous unemployment rate,” Weber told swissinfo.ch in an exclusive interview. “Regardless of the method used, a similar result is achieved: cross-border workers do not put Swiss residents out of work.”
Nearly 315,000 cross-border workers commute daily between their French, German, Italian or Austrian homes and their Swiss workplace. That is 6% of the total active workforce in Switzerland; a rate that rises to more than 30% in cantons Geneva, Basel City and Ticino.
While their massive presence often raises concerns and even rejection, it has little negative impact on the local labour market, according to a study by three Swiss economists. The study looks at two decades worth of data drawn from across Switzerland rather than focusing on just one region.
“A company seeks to hire qualified personnel where it is established,” notes Weber, a researcher at the University of Neuchâtel. “If it does not find the profiles it is looking for, it may be forced to relocate part of its activities. Thanks to the border workers, it can therefore maintain its activities on the spot, which will also benefit the local workforce.
In Geneva, the Geneva Citizens’ Movement (Mouvement Citoyens Genevois)External link has made the rejection of frontier workers its electoral business. But the researchers who analysed the data of the western canton found no causal link between the unemployment rate and the number of cross-border workers.
French-speaking cantons have unemployment rates well above the 2.9% national average: Neuchatel (5.3%), Geneva (4.9%), Jura (4.0%) and Vaud (4.11%). The explanation, according to Weber, lies more in the structure of the labour market than the impact of cross-border workers.
In German-speaking Switzerland, vocational training is much more widespread than in French-speaking Switzerland, which is more oriented towards French-language academic training, he notes. Young people find work much more quickly when they leave an apprenticeship, which has an impact on the overall unemployment rate.
Popular Stories
More
Workplace Switzerland
Meet the foreigners who make up a quarter of the Swiss population
What can be done to protect biodiversity in your country?
Swiss voters are set to decide on a people’s initiative calling for better protection of ecosystems in the country. Have your say on the September 22 vote.
Switzerland to host Ukraine mine action conference in October
This content was published on
Together with Ukraine, Switzerland is organising the Ukraine Mine Action Conference (UMAC2024) in Lausanne on October 17 and 18.
Switzerland revises pension expenditure downwards by billions
This content was published on
The Swiss government has corrected downwards the projected expenditure on old-age and survivor insurance in 2033 by CHF2.5 billion ($2.66 billion).
Excess mortality rate post-Covid could persist until 2033
This content was published on
According to a report by reinsurer Swiss Re, many countries are still experiencing excess mortality following the Covid-19 pandemic.
Swiss Army ends clean-up operation in storm-hit Maggia Valley
This content was published on
The Swiss Armed Forces completed 76 flight hours during the clean-up operation following the storm in the Maggia Valley in Ticino at the end of June.
Swiss cruise ship stranded on Danube River after heavy rains
This content was published on
Passengers on a Swiss river-cruise ship stranded on the Danube following heavy rainfall are still unable to disembark in Vienna due to flooding.
Golden eagles get better at flying over time, say Swiss researchers
This content was published on
Golden eagles perfect their flight as they age and learn to make better use of air currents, says a new study co-produced by Swiss researchers.
This content was published on
Public libraries in Switzerland recorded 46.3 million admissions last year, 7.4 million more than in 2022, says the Federal Statistical Office.
Swiss conservative party seeks referendum against Eurovision contest
This content was published on
The Swiss Federal Democratic Union is launching a referendum to prevent the Eurovision Song Contest from taking place in Basel next year.
Switzerland nabs 15 medals at WorldSkills championship
This content was published on
Swiss professionals have won 15 medals at the WorldSkills Championships in Lyon, France for the best finish by a European nation.
One dead, 2 children seriously injured after car crashes into Geneva sports centre
This content was published on
An 80-year-old driver crashed into several children aged around ten on Saturday after losing control of her vehicle in Geneva, before succumbing to her injuries.
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.
Read more
More
Swiss remind Italy over cross-border tax deal
This content was published on
Foreign minister Ignazio Cassis, says Switzerland is still waiting for an Italian decision on an agreement to tax cross-border workers.
Court rules on jobless benefit for cross-border worker
This content was published on
A cross-border worker has been denied the right to claim unemployment benefits from the Swiss authorities after her limited contract ran out.
This content was published on
From 1 January 2019, Switzerland will be the only country in Europe where employees’ taxes are not deducted directly from their wages.
This content was published on
The new “QuickZoll” smartphone app aims to simplify customs clearance for holidaymakers and cross-border shoppers, but it has limitations.
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.