Switzerland’s highest court has ruled that former private banker and whistleblower Rudolf Elmer did not breach banking secrecy law in a case that has garnered international attention.
The Federal Court rejected by three votes to two an appeal by Zurich prosecutors who were pushing for the country’s banking secrecy law to apply to whistleblowers wherever they are in the world.
The majority of the federal judges pointed out that Rudolf Elmer was no longer employed by a Swiss bank at the time of the events, Swiss news agency Keystone-SDA reported.
Elmer was the Chief Operating Officer of the Caribbean operations of the Swiss bank, Julius Baer, for eight years before being dismissed in 2002.
After his dismissal, Elmer sent threatening messages to bank employees and forwarded customer data to the media and tax authorities of several cantons and the federal government.
Only two judges upheld the view the view that the Julius Baer bank had delegated tasks to its subsidiary JBBT in the Cayman Islands, in which Rudolf Elmer worked. According to them, the Banking Act would also apply to third parties mandated by Swiss banks.
The case was seen as a test on whether the principle of Swiss banking secrecy could be enforced extra-territorially.
Bypassing bank secrecy
Swiss-regulated banks are legally bound to keep client information confidential, but whistleblowers have leaked account details to foreign authorities cracking down on tax evasion.
“It was made clear by the court that Swiss bank secrecy law is not applicable to banks in countries outside of Switzerland,” the former banker’s attorney, Ganden Tethong, told Reuters.
With this decision, the Federal Court confirmed the judgment handed down by the Zurich court in August 2016, which found Elmer guilty of threat and forgery of documents.
At the time, Elmer, who has made it his mission to erode the principles of Swiss banking secrecy, was given a suspended 14-month prison sentence.
The whistleblower has had multiple cases brought against him for sharing information about tax evasion, money laundering and other financial violations.
In 2016, Julius Baer paid $547 (CHF543) million in fines after the United States government filed criminal charges against the bank over tax fraud.
It also paid a fine of €50 (CHF57) million to the German government to avoid prosecution.
More
More
Whistleblowers to get new legal guidelines
This content was published on
Workplace whistleblowers are to be better protected by law. But a transparency group says the move does not go far enough.
Stress research: voting campaigns can trigger stress among minorities
This content was published on
Researchers at the University of Zurich showed in a study that they released more stress hormones during the referendum campaign.
Swiss justice minister advocates for greater sovereignty through bilateral agreements
This content was published on
In a networked world, sovereignty can be enhanced by regulating relations with important partners, Jans wrote in a NZZ commentary on Tuesday.
No heat records in sight (yet) despite the ‘dog days’
This content was published on
The dog days—traditionally the hottest days of the year—began on Tuesday. However, the weather service Meteonews predicts that Switzerland is unlikely to see new temperature records in the near future.
Swiss employees to work slightly more in 2023 than in previous year
This content was published on
The long-term trend is different with the weekly working hours per full-time employee decreased significantly, says a report by the Federal Statistical Office.
Consumers still crave chocolate: Lindt & Sprüngli reports higher earnings
This content was published on
Lindt & Sprüngli sold chocolate worth CHF 2.16 billion in the first half of the year. This is slightly more than in the previous year.
This content was published on
Bollinger will succeed Philipp Rickenbacher, who resigned in February after a significant write-down on loans to the Signa Group.
Majority of young Swiss well-trained, army fitness test reveals
This content was published on
More than half of young Swiss men and women are considered well-trained, with around 80% meeting the federal government's exercise recommendations, according to the Armed Forces 2023 fitness test.
Italian consulate to relocate to ‘Casa d’Italia’ in Zurich
This content was published on
The Italian state is renovating the "Casa d'Italia" in Zurich's Kreis 4 district, with plans to move the Consulate General from its current location on Tödistrasse in District 2 to this historic building.
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.
Read more
More
Swiss-US tax data transfer method ‘violates law’
This content was published on
The Swiss Supreme Court has already issued a ruling that bans the indiscriminate disclosure of people’s names without forewarning the individuals involved. This applies even when Switzerland has a treaty to automatically exchange tax information with other countries, as it does with 30 nations including the US. These treaties were signed following a US criminal…
As trust declines globally, can Switzerland remain an exception?
This content was published on
Switzerland is one of the most trusted countries despite being home to some of the largest companies in the most distrusted sectors.
This content was published on
With a payment of €300 million, the Swiss subsidiary of British bank HSBC has settled its tax fraud dispute with the French authorities.
Swiss prosecutors seek widening of secrecy law to bankers abroad
This content was published on
Swiss prosecutors are seeking a court ruling to make it easier to convict bank whistleblowers wherever they are in the world.
This content was published on
Announcing the settlement on Tuesday, the Department of Justice (DoJ) said the bank had deliberately poached clients from other Swiss banks that were themselves facing criminal actions in the US. Sensing the 2009 prosecution of UBS as a “business opportunity”, Basel Cantonal Bank engaged outside professionals to help them onboard US clients and their undeclared…
Golden opportunity for fragmented Swiss private banks
This content was published on
The annual study of Swiss private banking by KPMG and the University of St Gallen has found some signs for optimism following a decade of gloom. Profits across the 90 banks surveyed have risen along with assets under management (AuM), which had swollen to CHF2.6 trillion ($2.65 trillion) by the end of last year. “2017…
The business of secrecy has become even more lucrative, says whistleblower
This content was published on
Swiss whistleblower Rudolf Elmer tells Indian publication The Wire that tax evasion is still common despite international pressure to end it.
Five things a whistleblower has to say about tax havens
This content was published on
The Panama Papers scandal will not stop tax havens Eleven million documents revealing the offshore banking practices of Mossak Fonseca show that Swiss banks (Credit Suisse Channel Islands Ltd., HSBC Private Bank Suisse, UBS AG) and Swiss lawyers are major players in offshore banking.Elmer: “The tax havens are certainly not dying out. The practices will…
‘Whistleblower’ Rudolf Elmer given suspended sentence
This content was published on
Judge brands Elmer an "ordinary criminal" - not a whistleblower - as the former Julius Bär banker is found guilty of issuing threats.
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.