Committee blasts detention of young rejected asylum seekers
It is estimated that up to a third of asylum seekers slated for deportation go into hiding.
Keystone
A Swiss parliamentary committee has criticised the use of administrative detention to hold young rejected asylum seekers saying it goes too far. It has urged the government to “put its house in order” and stop the practice.
Between 2011 and 2014, a total of 200 underage asylum seekers were held in Swiss prisons because their deportation was imminent, according to a report by the House of Representatives’ Control Committee published on Thursday.
Cantons may order administrative detention if there are fears a person may attempt to evade deportation and if the removal is likely to happen soon. However, administration detention must not exceed 18 months (12 months for minors over 15).
Some cantons expressly refrain from detaining minors, including Neuchâtel, Vaud and Geneva. In others, like Bern, children under the age of 15 are often imprisoned together with their relatives, even if only for a few days, the report says. This practice is justified by the fact that the authorities do not want to separate children from their parents or relatives.
“Unnecessary hardship”
However, for Swiss People’s Party parliamentarian Alfred Heer, who oversaw the committee’s report, this practice has gone too far.
“Unnecessary hardship towards families with small children or towards minors should be avoided,” says Heer, who otherwise advocates a strict asylum practice.
The committee said the practice contravenes the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and under Swiss law under-15-year-olds should not be detained for deportation. In 2016, the Federal Court ruled that children aged 10-15 can be held in custody under exceptional circumstances.
The committee warned the use of administrative detention to ensure the return of asylum seekers was not uniform across Switzerland’s 26 cantons, raising the risk of “borderline legal” practices. It urged the government to “put its house in order” on the issue of administrative detention.
The committee found a wide divergence of practices between cantons. While the discrepancies may in part be explained by the age, sex or country of origin of the applicants, it still did not account for the differences between cantons. For example, in canton Obwalden 61% of rejected asylum seekers were under administrative detention, compared to 24% in canton Geneva.
Another major criticism was the mismanagement of data by the government. It is therefore not possible to know how many persons scheduled to be deported have gone into hiding. The committee estimates the proportion of such cases to be as high as a third of unsuccessful asylum applicants.
Criticism rejected
The Bern cantonal authorities on Friday rejected the criticism, saying the detention of children with their families was a measure of last resort used in one or two cases a year only.
They said their policy was in line with legal requirements and people were never kept in detention for more than 48 hours.
Swiss investigate four people linked to Russian oligarch
This content was published on
The Office of the Attorney General of Switzerland is investigating four individuals linked to Russian oligarch Suleyman Kerimov.
Swiss government scrambles to deal with egg shortage
This content was published on
From September 1, more eggs intended for consumption may be imported into Switzerland. In allowing this, the government wants to secure the supply of eggs for consumers.
This content was published on
Agricultural research sees new development opportunities for Swiss sparkling wines in the face of declining wine consumption. In a survey, half of consumers expressed a willingness to pay more for local products than for foreign ones.
Locarno spotlights filmmakers from South America and Caribbean
This content was published on
The Open Doors section of the Locarno Film Festival has named the winners for 2024. The spotlight is on the South American and Caribbean regions.
Storm paralyses trains to popular Swiss tourist resort
This content was published on
The railway line between Zweilütschinen and Grindelwald in central Switzerland is expected to remain closed until Friday following heavy rains.
NGO blasts Swiss policy on detaining migrant children
This content was published on
The Swiss non-governmental organisation Terre des hommes has criticised Switzerland’s ‘illegal’ and opaque policy of detaining unaccompanied minor refugees.
Switzerland urged to improve protection of vulnerable migrants
This content was published on
In a report on Switzerland, published on TuesdayExternal link, Nils Muižnieks calls on the Swiss authorities to end its “traumatising” practice of detaining young migrant children in airport transit zones with or without their parents for up to 60 days while they await a decision on their asylum status. “They usually wouldn’t detain a child…
Asylum applications drop by a third in Switzerland
This content was published on
According to the State Secretariat for Migration (SEM) the decline in applications is largely due to two factors. First, a drop in migration along the central Mediterranean route from mid-July onwards. Second, fewer migrant arrivals from conflict zones like Afghanistan, Syria and Iraq, which were quite significant at the beginning of 2016. The majority of…
Are the Swiss too strict about the Dublin accords?
This content was published on
Our data shows Switzerland’s strict application of the Dublin accords means migrants are sent to a country where they weren't officially registered.
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.