Almost three quarters of new doctors in Switzerland in 2019 had studied abroad, the NZZ am Sonntag newspaper has revealed. The figures show how much the Swiss health system relies on foreign doctors, the report says.
Around 4,000 people received the Swiss authorities’ blessing to practice medicine last year, the newspaper saidExternal link on Sunday, citing recently published statisticsExternal link from the Federal Office of Public Health. Almost three quarters of them – around 2,900 – had trained abroad and received official recognition of their qualifications.
The number of foreign doctors has been rising in Switzerland over the last decade, mostly due to the free movement of people agreement between the European Union and non-member Switzerland, the paper said.
Most of the foreign doctors came from neighbouring countries Germany (1,208), Italy (352) and France (258). There was a significant number from eastern Europe. “The number of Romanian doctors has increased tenfold over the last decade, to reach almost 150 last year,” the NZZ am Sonntag said.
Dependence
The Federal Office of Public Health told the newspaper that the situation was “not ideal”. But the Swiss Medical AssociationExternal link went further. “We have been calling for a long time for each country to train enough doctors. The fact that Switzerland has neglected this over the past 20 years is now plain to see,” a spokeswoman said.
She added that it was going to get harder to recruit enough qualified medical staff because Switzerland’s neighbours also had a lack of doctors and their working conditions – often cited as a reason for doctors to move to Switzerland – were improving.
The Swiss Conference of Cantonal Health Directors took the same line. “The reliance on foreign countries makes the system vulnerable, especially in crisis times,” a spokesman said.
Currently of the almost 38,000 doctors working in Switzerland, around a third of them qualified abroad.
In 2016 the government announced extra measures, including CHF100 million ($104 million) for extra medicine courses, to ensure there were enough home-trained doctors in Switzerland. The aim was to produce 1,300 Swiss-trained doctors a year from 2025. Last year there were around 1,100, up from around 1,000 in 2018.
More
More
Addressing the shortage of Swiss doctors
This content was published on
Switzerland has by all accounts, a well-working, although very expensive, health system. At first glance, there would seem to be enough doctors. With 4.0 doctors per 1,000 of the population, Switzerland comes in at 7th on the 2013 OECD listings for the number of doctors per 1,000 of the population. This puts it on a…
In banking, Switzerland can’t afford ‘model pupil syndrome’, says UBS CEO
This content was published on
UBS Group CEO Sergio Ermotti says competition between banks in Switzerland will continue even following the takeover of rival Credit Suisse.
Switzerland to chair international forum on migration
This content was published on
Switzerland will chair the Intergovernmental Consultations on Asylum, Refugees and Migration (IGC) in 2025, the government announced on Monday.
Y2K anniversary: Swiss preparations to dodge the millennium bug
This content was published on
The idea that computers around the world could fail at midnight on December 31, 1999 put many on alert. In the end, not much went wrong.
‘Switzerland needs a stable relationship with its neighbours,’ says foreign minister
This content was published on
"We are once again entering an 'America first, Europe first, Switzerland first' logic," Ignazio Cassis said in an interview published Monday.
Jimmy Carter supported Swiss-backed peace effort for Middle East
This content was published on
Former United States President Jimmy Carter maintained close ties with Switzerland and had expressed gratitude for the country's efforts on the Geneva peace initiative.
Swiss cowfighting championship at risk of being cancelled
This content was published on
Despite growing popularity, the national Hérens cowfighting championship could be cancelled in 2025 for lack of organisers.
This content was published on
More young doctors are taking over family doctor surgeries. But it is still not enough to stem the shortage of general practitioners (GPs).
This content was published on
The shortage of skilled workers has become even more acute this year. Finding suitable engineers is particularly difficult.
Swiss doctors call for better supplies of vaccines
This content was published on
Carlos Quinto, a board member of the Swiss Medical AssociationExternal link (FMH), told the Swiss public broadcaster SRFExternal link that stocks of Pneumovax, which helps patients with respiratory diseases or immune deficiencies to ward off pneumonia, have run out. “Patients are calling us and we then have to tell them that there is nothing left,”…
This content was published on
As people live longer, the need for doctors who can deal with the issues facing the elderly is growing. However, the job of a geriatrician is losing out to other medical disciplines, such as neurosurgery or cardiology, in the battle for new recruits.
The intensive care unit at Bern University Hospital is busy. Nurses check monitors and change bandages of patients hooked up to beeping machines. Doctors travel in a group from bed to bed, transferring information at one of the three daily handovers.
Out of 51 beds, 40 to 45 are generally filled, says Stephan Jakob, chief physician for interdisciplinary intermediate care. And the average age in the unit is increasing.
“Ten years ago, it was not much above 60,” he says. “Now the average age is 65, but with a huge range, up to 90-95. And there are procedures which we didn’t use, let’s say ten years ago, for older patients, like transplantation, invasive treatment for stroke, artificial hearts. Now, because patients are getting older, these are increasingly used also for these patients, and they stay longer than the younger patients. So we need more beds.”
The needs of the ageing
Many problems that affect the elderly begin at a point where people don’t think of themselves as old. Already by the age of 50, one in five Swiss residents suffers from two or more chronic illnesses simultaneously, according to the Swiss Health Observatory. And patients aged 75 to 84 made up a fifth of all patients in Swiss acute care hospitals in 2012. In the United Kingdom, the average patient is more than 80 years old.
Treating the elderly requires special knowledge, says Thomas Münzer, president of the Swiss Geriatric Society and a chief physician in St Gallen. “They mostly have three or four or five different medical problems which need to be managed very carefully. And here we need to have the information about the biology of ageing, and we have to know that an old body functions differently from a younger body,” he says.
Training new doctors
There are special knowledge or skills needed for medical care of older people, and they have to be learnt, says Andreas Stuck, who heads the geriatrics department at Bern University Hospital.
Future doctors first need to learn the special ways disease appears in older persons. They need to learn how to communicate. They need to consider ethical issues, such as “whether you choose very proactive care with very intense treatment in a 90-year-old person as compared with palliative pain relief”. For this, they need to have special knowledge and skills for diagnosis and management of diseases in older patients, Stuck says.
To help standardise what medical students learn about geriatrics, Stuck and a group of European researchers collected input from 49 experts in 29 countries to develop consensus on a ten-point list of minimum requirements – knowledge and skills that new doctors should possess after medical school. The study, published in March 2014, concluded: “Major efforts will be needed to implement these requirements, given the large variation in the quality of geriatric teaching in medical schools.”
Furthermore, it’s not just young medical students who have to learn to deal with elderly patients: physicians must respond to the needs of older patients throughout their careers, Stuck says.
Specialists vs generalists
Geriatricians – physicians who specialise in the ageing population – serve in a variety of settings, from hospital care and home care to long-term care and terminal care. They are also involved in overseeing geriatric care and geriatric education.
Jürg Schlup, president of the Swiss Medical Association, says it’s reasonable to require a university hospital’s geriatrics department to be headed by a geriatrician. But according to Münzer, not until 2014 did every Swiss medical faculty have a chair in geriatrics, “so we are far behind in terms of training and education”.
In Switzerland it’s not just geriatricians who care for old people. “The majority of healthcare for older people is provided by family physicians, by hospital physicians, by specialists who have responsibilities for care of older people,” says Stuck. Thus “whatever discipline you choose, you will need special training in geriatrics as part of your training, and that covers the span from pre-graduate to postgraduate training.”
The Swiss doctor shortage
Providing specialised care for the elderly is complicated by the fact that in Switzerland there is a shortage of doctors overall.
“This lack of doctors has its roots in four principal developments in our country,” says the SMA’s Schlup.
“First, the number of medical students is too low. Second, the demand for services is increasing with the ageing of the population. Third, the number of doctors working part-time is growing. And fourth, the number of hours physicians are legally allowed to work per week was reduced from 60 to 50” in 2005.
Currently, about one third of the physician workforce in Switzerland is hired abroad, says Schlup, and in ten years that proportion is expected to increase to 50%.
“Thanks to the foreign physicians we’re doing well,” says Schlup. “But Germany, which exports its doctors, is now trying to get them back. We can’t run the system without them.”
Already, medical disciplines are fighting to attract enough young doctors. “If you work for a surgery department or an internal medicine department or a dermatology department, there is very big competition” to recruit students, says Schlup. That means there are even fewer potential candidates for careers in geriatrics.
Who will choose geriatrics?
“We are desperately seeking young physicians who are interested in training in geriatrics,” says Münzer.
But today’s medical students “want to become sports medicine physicians or ophthalmologists or neurosurgeons or whatever,” he says. “Nobody really says, ‘I want to become a geriatrician’. But I think some people make the decision later in their career.”
Gianna Negri, a young assistant physician in the geriatrics department of Bern’s Ziegler hospital, says she hasn’t decided whether she wants to become a geriatrician, but she likes working with old patients.
“A lot of young doctors think geriatrics isn’t exciting, she says, “but I don’t agree at all. I don’t find it boring. We have a lot of days that are challenging and full of action.”
“I think I have one of the most interesting professions existing,” says Stuck, who chose geriatrics in the 1980s.
Münzer, too, is satisfied with his career choice.
“It’s not that spectacular compared with cardiac surgery or neurosurgery,” says Münzer. “You can’t make a lot of money with it. And you’re treating diseases that are not very sexy, like dementia or frailty or falls and fractures and osteoporosis.”
Still, treating the elderly is “intriguing and fantastic”, he says. Every patient is different, and every approach is individual. “And if you look at the numbers, actually, this is the field of the future.”
Some health issues associated with ageing include falls and bone fractures, incontinence, malnutrition, osteoporosis, Parkinson’s syndrome, dementia including Alzheimer’s disease, bed sores (in bedridden patients), multiple medications and drug interactions, loss of autonomy, and the dying process.
The birth of geriatrics
Geriatric medicine was developed by pioneers in the United Kingdom in the late 1800s and early 1900s. In 2012, geriatricians were the largest group of consultant physicians (1,252 out of 12,221) belonging to the Royal College of Physicians. In Switzerland, on the other hand, geriatrics is a relatively new discipline.
The Swiss Gerontological Society, founded in 1953, is a national organisation focusing on the subjects of “old age” and “ageing”. But of its 1,400 individual members, only around 300 are actually geriatricians and organised in a daughter society, the Swiss Geriatric Society.
It wasn’t until 2000 that the Swiss Medical Association, under the auspices of the Swiss Institute for Continuing Medical Education, developed a three-year specialisation in geriatrics for doctors with degrees in general internal medicine.
You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!
If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at english@swissinfo.ch.